Start a new thread

1 to 20 of 22 replies

Hello, can anybody identify what these are? They are growing in my fron garden quite close to the house. We would like to keep them but if they are going to be very big they'll have to go.

 

Thanks in advance.

 


 


 

nutcutlet

The top one look like an ash tree Stu

The bottom one is a treeas well, maybe a cherry.

Both BIG

nutcutlet

Not 100% sure of cherry but looks like its manner of growth. Look around the area and see what trees there are about. Ash keys blow in the wind, cherries are delivered by birds unless you have an overhanging tree.

fidgetbones

If the cherry (bottom one) is more than 15ft away from the house you might getaway with it if it a grafted one. If it is set by the birds and a wild one, well one near us has grown to 30ft in 15 years. The Ash I would definitely have out.

Advertisement

The first one (Ash??) is about 1.5m from the house and the second (possibly cherry??) is 3m.

Would you suggest removing both?

Thanks

 

fidgetbones

As soon as possible. Don't let them get entrenched. If you can't dig them out, chop them off as low as possible and then treat any regrowth with Glyphosate.

nutcutlet

Get rid of them while they're still small Stu. If you want a small tree get one that you know is small. These are not garden trees unless you have at least half an acre, possibly more than that. 

 

fidgetbones

Can I suggest buddlejas instead?. Flowers attract butterflies, they have a lovely honey scent, and you can keep them under control by cutting down to 1ft every year in March.

Fairygirl

That last pic looks like beech or hornbeam foliage- difficult to tell as we can't enlarge. Hornbeam has a more 'pronounced' crinkle though.

Thanks for the advice everyone - maybe i could transfer the cherry to the bottom of back garden.

nutcutlet

If you've got room any of those trees, ash, cherry, hornbeam, beech, all lovely and give you some summer shade. My wild cherries have very edible fruit as well.

How far away from the house would you recommend the Cherry?

nutcutlet

I think they grow to about 100 feet. 4 of mine are about 30 feet fronm the house and although it's ok now I think in time that will be too close.

I wouldn't do it if I were you, there are so many attractive small and productive trees suitable for a garden that to introduce something so big and only maybe producing something edible seems like a waste of garden space. I'm lucky with some of my cherries but wild ones can be a bit sour (or so I'm told)

These trees are lovely if you want shade - but do your neighbors want the shade too - some trees as they get well rooted can bring a lot of problems with getting into the property . Where we used to live our nextdoor family got the roots of a tree coming through into the lounge .  . outside the path had cracked , they thought nothing of it , thought it was just deteriating  that was until a floor board split , inspected the damage found a sapling forcing its way through. 

Advertisement

Busy-Lizzie

Wild cherries here are very sweet (when properly ripe), but not much flesh for a big stone. But I agree with Fairygirl - beech or hornbeam for the 2nd one.

What trees would you recommend for a smaller back garden (44ftx32ft) ?

Busy-Lizzie

Crab apples, amalanchier, one of the smaller flowering cherries.

Well the first tree looks like this now. Maybe someone knows what it is now?