Start a new thread

1 to 7 of 7 replies

Andrew Kenneth


In December I prepared various beds, weeding manuring etc... then, I sheeted them up with black 1000 micron visqueen.

Today when I pulled back the sheeting there was a carpet of fine weeds happily growing underneath the sheeting.

I presumed black sheeting would surpress them but that has not happened.

Why is this?

Any help appreciated



Many will have recently germinated from weed seeds in the soil because the sheeting has helped warm the soil up.  Others will be perennial weeds like dandelion which start coming up at this time of the year.  Because they will be unable to photosyntensize due to lack of light (I presume they are mostly white/yellow in colour?), they will die as long as you leave the sheeting in place.  To kill all weeds using weed suppressing membrane, you may need to leave it in place for a whole season.  As soon as you plant anything or turn the soil, dormant weed seeds will be brought to the surface though, so membrane is not a panacea.  There's an old gardeners saying that goes "One year's seed is seven years weeds." which is effectively how long it takes of diligent weeding before an area is as weed free as it is possible to make it.

If you have plants ready to go in, I would suggest making slits in the sheet and planting through it for now.  You could hide the sheet with bark chippings for the time being.  Keep peeking under the sheet and when the ground is clear later in the year, remove the bark and cut the rest of the sheet up (so you don't damage anything you have planted) to remove it.


I tried that years ago and the mice/voles/rats  that undermine our garden had a great time eating the spuds and other roots.

I think we have to live with weeds. I drive along our road in late summer and seeds from assorted compositae are drifting around. They're part of life.


I agree, nutcutlet.  It is useful to help with the initial clearing of a badly weed infested patch, but hand-weeding will always be necessary and is the best way.  I especially don't agree with the permanent laying of membrane as some councils and builders do as it just goes against nature, ruining the soil and natural soil ecosystem (eg starving worms for a start.)  I much prefer using a good depth of mulch as this suppresses weed seedling germination and the perennial weeds are easy to see so can be removed as soon as they poke their heads through.  A mulch will also feed the soil with little need to provide any extra feed. Win-Win.

Andrew Kenneth


Correct they are spindly white stalks with a yellow head...


Thank you




Absolutely Dove.

I couldn't garden without mine.

Sign up or log in to post a reply