Start a new thread

1 to 12 of 12 replies

Alan4711

Evening all, I have been to Homebase and noticed they are selling Multi Purpose Compost, on the bag it states   (( With added John Innes )) with John Innes being a formula  are they telling lies.

Alan.......I've never worked that one out either

I have tried various brands of JI............years ago, you could rely on the formula being followed to the T..............these days, nothing is at it seems IMO.

 

Welshonion
Maybe they have added some John Innes no. 1, 2 or 3. This is to fool (?) you that the multi-purpose is better than it is.

John Innes is a formula that is used to make up soil for specific potting purposes.

No, they are not lying, one hopes.
BobTheGardener

Yeah, it's meaningless.  They could have made a batch of compost, perfectly formulated to one of the JI standards (which one though?!) but then only added a teaspoonful!

WelshOnion.......Mmmmmm...........seems a bit stupid tho doesn't it ?  You either buy Multi purpose or you buy specific purpose............so little point in "added JI"..........particularly if they don't specify which JI formula they have supposedly added. 

I don't think it will fool most of us.......hopefully, they'll get the drift before too long and dump this particular advertising ploy.

Advertisement

nutcutlet

Poor old John Inne, has He been exhumed, ground up and added to the bags?

Nutcutlet ..  Judging by the way he is getting around these days, he must have been a really, really BIG bloke

Woodgreen wonderboy

J. Arthur Bowers Multi Purpose is very poor... but the MP plus JI is usable if more expensive. In this case there is a difference.

nutcutlet

the JAB MP is totally naff this year, the peat free isn't so bad

Alan4711

Hi Dove Sorry , that was one i missed when they were carving me up i think, I emptied the Darlek today as it wasn't doing anything and bagged and binned it all ,a messy load it was too, then Kate pointed out i had placed the darlek on pebbles so the worms would hardly get in to do there job, sometimes i just wonder where im coming from ,I  think i,ll blame the anesthetic. volunteered to do the ironing this morning, then ,decided to de scale the iron and blew the mains, comes in threes they say .

I think the mpc with John innes is heavier.  Prob more useful in containers that might otherwise blow over.  

Currently I'm usIng a levington mpc claiming to hold 20% more moisture...?  Well, it feels a little more substantial but mpc generally is pretty awful now.

Used to mix sieved soil and mpc for containers and thought it pretty good and had less attacks of vine weevil 

For any permanent container plantIng I would always use John innes

Sign up or log in to post a reply