Victor,
I wonder sometimes if the Beeb is trying to attract younger people to GARDENING by things like you mentioned on tonight's programme and possibly "the cool wall" - a spin-off from another well known popular programme (perhaps the planners are thinking the "formula" might work here?) or are they thinking that it might attract young people to the PROGRAMME?
So are they catering to a potential audience or their bread and butter like you and me?
Not sure this particular forum is the place to discuss this but since you brought it up here, I'll add my two-penn'th.
I like Toby, I like his style which is reminiscent of Geoff Hamilton who got me interested in gardening in the first place. I like Alys for the same reason - she's like the prodigy of Geoff Hamilton and Eddi Reader - recycling in Gardening ...with an edge!! ;0)
From Gardener's World on a Friday night, I personally want recycling tips, propagation tips, information about the plants in my garden (maybe a "plant of the week" feature would be good?), same old stuff about composting, lawn-care, pruning tips is what I tune in for - I am looking for inspiration as to how I will spend my weekend.
Entertainment is secondary really and when it becomes contrived and wastes my precious "fact-time" that could have been better filled with lovely details about things to tackle this weekend, I get annoyed (same as you do clearly!).
What happened to the gardening programmes on the other sides on a Friday night? I used to be able to change to Channel 4 after GW had finished?
Anyway, I started to think that I am out of date and not coping well with change but then they messed about with Countryfile too and made it "funky" in the same way and I decided that it's not me, it's a BBC high-level decision to formulae-alize programs to appeal to a younger/dumber audience (my guess) to sustain their existence long-term (I am a regular Countryfile viewer whom they lost with this policy but I'm sure they gained in the long run?).
If the programmes I mention continue to lean towards entertainment rather than documentary (as I see it), I will just lose interest and tune off (complaining as I go..) because there is no benefit in me watching the programmes.
I watch Gardener's World to rev me up for the weekend because I WILL be doing jobs anyway - I don't watch it as a substitute for things that I would like to do, but can't, because I have a hangover!
Cor, you hit a nerve eh Victor?
Perhaps this will be read by someone in BBC Planning (or passed to them) as a representative sample of the effect of the recent changes to Countryfile and GW on maybe 15 years(ish) of patronage from an older viewer?