Start a new thread

21 to 29 of 29 replies


I'm in the process of transferring the last two years of GW onto DVD. But it's a slow procedure. 

Big fan of Andy Sturgeon.  Toby Buckland too.  

Woodgreen wonderboy

I think it's about time we had some new blood presenting GW and Chelsea, and by new I don't mean young and wet behind the ears. I have had enough of MD, and AT has gone all silly. CB is probably the best of the current crop. CK is OK. I like AS and TB. RdT is fine. AF and SR can stay at home as far as I am concerned and JS probably too.  A new GH is what I need or AT before he went walkabout. Does anyone know of anyone else?

Bob flowerdew might be a breath of fresh air to GW.....bit eccentric but no doubting his knowledge.  He and Andy Sturgeon would make for a good blend.  I know Carol Kleine is popular here but she is too effervescent.  Christine Walkden is just as knowledgeable but less in your face 

Woodgreen wonderboy

What  a good combo.  BF and AS would do nicely. Much prefer CK to CW.


whaaaat? Monty is my fave by far! Maybe because I am a woman who finds his "Ted Hughes meets the flowerpot men" style appealing (see GW mag, November).............I also love Carol Klein's enthusiasm and they way she has mucky hands and rubbish nails, like a real gardener. I do miss Toby Buckland though, I think it was the garden he had to work with (not real) on Gardener's World that didn't work for viewers, not him.


I'm another Monty and Carol fan, although I do also have a lot of respect for several of the others mentioned (with the exception of Mr T who I think has other fish to fry - but then I've never been a fan of his)

However, I think the main problem is that the programme is too short.  If it were longer there would be time for more variety which would please those who like different gardening and presentation styles.

A lot of the filming done in other gardens is obviously going to be recycled and expanded on at a later date in those compilation programmes (possibly the ones scheduled for early December?).

As with most things in life - it's all down to budgets - MD can provide a garden from which to host the programme which can accomodate the cameras, crew etc rather than the BBC having to buy/lease somewhere  


Sign up or log in to post a reply