12 messages
22/04/2013 at 12:07

Hi everyone,

yesterday i caught a sneaky vine weevil upto no good on one of my pristine primulas.

Immediatly, I went  out and bought some vine beetle KILLER, but when I got home and studied the remedies I already have in my greenhouse, I came across my bayers all bug control.(which is a systemic product).

My quiery is could i have saved my money and just treat my potted primulas whith the Bayer stuff???

pete

22/04/2013 at 12:09
Was the weevil an adult or a grub?
22/04/2013 at 12:11

Yes!

And if you are careful with your ratios, you can also use it for Bayer Lawn Chafer Grub / Leatherjacket control, which comes as a powder in sachets but is teh same ingredient. . I worked out last year that it is around one tenth the cost oer square metre. 

22/04/2013 at 12:15

Figrat, the response would be the same either way. If it was an adult, it will have been laying eggs. Also, the active ingredient is absorbed in the leaves and kills insects that nibble them. 

22/04/2013 at 12:21

OH carefully saved a bug he had found this morning for me to see. I screamed Kill it quick -yep a vine weevil. OH didn't have a clue.

Last year he learnt about lily beetles, I suppose this years lesson will be vine weevils

22/04/2013 at 12:50

It was an adult and enjoying the leaves.........RIP! ...........not anymore.

So I could have saved my money and used the bayer systemic stuff eh!

Bayer list some of the bugs it will kill but why dont they mention this  pest.

22/04/2013 at 12:54
I'm not sure Provado vine weevil killed is the same as bayern bug co trol. You need a generous dilute mix of Provado for vine weevil control.
I use Provado ...would not use bug control.
Nematodes are very effective from may onwards....the growing season...but not right now so Provado is the solution
22/04/2013 at 13:25

You are right Verdun. I should have read the post more carefully. Bayer make a pesticide called Provado Ultimate Bug Killer, which has the same active ingredient as Provado Vine Weevil Killer, i.e. thiacloprid., in the same concentration, 9 grams per litre. they sell at around the same price, around £8 for 400ml.

Their Vine Weevil Killer used to use a very similar ingredient, imidacloprid, but the formula changed (they now call it vine Weevil Killer 2! I think it was in response to concerns about imidacloprid and bees. Imidacloprid is still used in their Lawn Grub Killer, and the thiacloprid products can be used instead, provided you do the maths and get the concentration right. There is a BIG saving. 

22/04/2013 at 21:01

what do vine weevil eggs look like?

29/07/2013 at 15:50

I live in The Netherlands. I had never heard of the Vine Weevil, Dutch name Taxus Kever. At first, I thought my climbing Hydrenga was being attacked by Snails. When my Snail korrels didn't help, I researched the Dutch internet and found out about these little devils. I am using Bayer's Bio1020 compost to fight the Taxus Kever. Bought from Citytree in Ridderkerk (NL). Their supplier is Van Iersel in Udenhout (NL). It is compost containing a fungus especially developed to kill the weevil, the larve and eggs. It takes about 3 days to work.

29/07/2013 at 16:19

The main ingredient in Provado...thiacloprid.....has also been linked to depleting numbers in bee population  If the plant is in the ground it will survive beetle damage and grubs will be eaten by predators. If in a pot put a bit of landscape fabric in the bottom, leaves no access through drainage holes, and give the top of the pot a thick layer of gravel/grit etc. Beetles can't lay.

29/07/2013 at 16:43

The bio 1020 is a natural product. I can even use it In my herb garden without having to worry about eating the herbs.

email image
12 messages