London (change)
Today 13°C / 8°C
Tomorrow 13°C / 9°C


Latest posts by Italophile

Tomato leaf problems - help

Posted: 08/07/2012 at 09:36

Gard, check my post just above your last one. Your problem, in this instance, isn't over-watering. It's disease. I'll get back to you on it. And your follow-up questions.

Tomato leaf problems - help

Posted: 08/07/2012 at 09:03
Gard wrote (see)

Hi All. Went to my greenhouse this morning and the problem has worsened. In various stages, it's near to the top of the plants.

I have taken off some of the worst affected leaves and taken photo's of the same, which will hopefully be attached


. Can anyone give me a definitive answer to what the problem is, and the most expeditious remedy.

 N.B. I have two other identical tomato plants, planted exactly the same way (compost, tubs etc) outdoors. Other than the fact that they are slightly less advanced than those in the pictures, they are in perfect health, even after suffering the almost daily deluge of the past few months. The only difference is that God is watering them, not me.

Gard, that's not a watering problem. It looks either fungal or bacterial. I'll get back to you, but, in the meantime, if you can, move the affected plants away from any healthy ones nearby.

Tomato leaf problems - help

Posted: 08/07/2012 at 08:58

That's odd. It missed the last bit of the post. Maybe the software got bored with all the words.

Anyway, here's what was missing:

It means establishing the plant's requirements and watering - approximately the same amount - accordingly.

My plants, in the ground, in (obviously) the same weather conditions as Ettore's plant, are watered every four or five days, very very very deeply, driving the roots down deep into the soil for their moisture, away from the heat of the surface soil. And they love it.

Sorry about writing a book.


Tomato leaf problems - help

Posted: 08/07/2012 at 08:28
sotongeoff wrote (see)

Why are you watering them so much-this is the problem-there is a tomato expert on this forum-italiophile-who constantly says they need tough love to grow properly.

Easeback on the watering-let them dry out-remove some of the yellowing leaves -only a few -not all and they will be fine

Just not so much water.

Geoff is right. The biggest mistake you can make with toms is watering by rote - automatically, regardless of conditions. The rule of thumb is simple: water toms when they need it. When do they need it? When the mix - in the case of containers - dries out. You can let the mix dry out. It will not hurt the plant. Leaving the mix dry for a week obviously will hurt the plant but over a day it won't.

There's a myth that toms are delicate plants. They're not. By nature, historically, genetically, they're tough, robust individuals that will survive in adverse conditions. Watering a tom in a container once a day - let alone twice a day - amounts to overwatering. Here's a case in point -

Every year I give our (now) 8 year-old neighbour, Ettore, a tom in a pot. He loves gardening, he watches me from his window in my orto (vegie garden) and, one day, wants to help me. His care for the tom amounts to counting the fruit. His mum, Paola, does all the work. This year it's a Camp Joy (aka Chadwick's Cherry) cherry in a relatively small container.

Now, they have no garden at all. The plant lives outside their front door. It gets about 6 hours a day of full sun. And the temperatures have been in the mid-30s for the last month. Paola waters her window boxes every day. I've had almost to break one of her arms to stop her watering the tom every day. Even 6 hours a day of direct mid-30s sun doesn't completely dry out the mix in a day.

She asked me why the leaves were yellowing. I told her the roots were constantly damp. She was over-watering. I told her that toms aren't flowers in a window box. They're a different beast with different requirements. I got her to stick a finger deep down into the mix. Sure enough, deep down, where the roots are, the mix was damp.

Finally, I've got her watering every second day. The yellow leaves are disappearing and the plant is starting to fruit.

Many of the problems that arise for the home tomato grower come about when the plants' natural sturdiness is overwhelmed by pampering - over-watering and over-feeding. Pampering a tomato plant doesn't strengthen it. It weakens it. An over-watered and over-fed plant is more vulnerable to disease and other problems.

In simple terms, producing fruit is a plant's means of reproducing itself. Tomatoes will feel more inclined to reproduce themselves if they feel ever so slightly threatened. It's their inbuilt survival mechanism. That's what you need to exploit to maximise production. Call it what you like - tough love, controlled neglect - but it's the exact opposite of pampering.

As lilylouise rightly says above, irregular watering is thought to be one of the factors contributing to Blossom End Rot - no one actually knows for sure - so the watering pattern needs to be regular. That doesn't have to mean every day. It means establishing the plant's requirements and watering - app

Advice on repotting my tomato plants please.

Posted: 07/07/2012 at 08:01

I'd plant into normal compost and fertilise separately. Bearing in mind that (a) toms don't like overly rich soil; and (b) don't need a lot of fertiliser. It's a common tendency to pamper tomatoes with lots of water and fertiliser. In fact, they will perform better - produce more fruit - if made to struggle a bit. "Tough love" is the go. Fertilise when the first fruit appears, then - if the roots are confined, as in pots, etc - no more than once a month afterwards. Mine, in the ground, are fed a couple of weeks after planting out, again when the first fruit sets, then only once more later in the season.


Posted: 06/07/2012 at 17:35

Sounds like too much water to me. It would need to be pretty warm for toms in the ground to need water every two days. Heck, it's in the high 30s here, the toms are in full sun, and I don't water mine more than once a week. But very very deeply when I do water.

Some Squash is Turning Soft

Posted: 06/07/2012 at 08:15

Agree. Unfertilised - or not completely fertilised - fruit will wither and die.

Beetroot cyclindra

Posted: 05/07/2012 at 14:16


what is the red chilli for please?

Posted: 05/07/2012 at 14:11

Or cold shoulders, if they're of the sweet - rather than hot - variety.

Beetroot cyclindra

Posted: 05/07/2012 at 09:08

Could be. If it is, that makes removing them even more difficult without disturbing the surrounding plants.

Might be an idea to feel down into the soil around the roots of the interloper. It will reveal what's underneath.

Discussions started by Italophile

Italophile has not started any discussions