Scrapbook image

Your scrapbook

Forgotten your details?

Enter your email address and we'll send your username and password to you

London

  • CloudyToday
    9°C/17°C
  • CloudyTomorrow
    7°C/15°C
  • See Gardeners'
    7-day forecast

Our Gardeners' 7-day forecast warns you of changing weather conditions (including frost, high wind and drought) and suggests actions to take to protect your plants.

Advertisement

Gardeners World blog

RSS RSS | What is RSS?

Gardeners' musings

Sieving compost

Posted by: Pippa Greenwood, 07 February 2008, 11.09AM

Compost Like many gardeners at this time of year, I can normally be found in the garden with my head in a bag of compost. I'm not hiding from the taxman, or even two noisy kids - I'm just trying to get some seeds sown.

Sowing seeds is a task that should be relaxing and fill me with feelings of excitement and satisfaction. And how could it not? I'm literally sowing the seeds of great things to eat and to look at. Sadly I'm finding the task increasingly irritating.

The seeds are as good quality as ever and the trays are well used and very efficient. Even my ancient propagator works well, although it's in much need of a new lid as the plastic is badly cracked and discoloured.

It is the COMPOST that infuriates me.

I know the price of compost goes down, sometimes year-on-year (although the bag size of many types has also decreased slightly too), but is it me, or am I right in feeling that the compost itself is getting lumpier and lumpier?

More and more sizeable lumps of partially-composted wood clutter up the bags of compost, and on two occasions I even found two pieces of glass. Yes, I own a compost sieve and no, I'm not necessarily talking about composts based on recycled materials. But although I can and do use the sieve, and my son's fingers' were not actually cut when his small hand came across the glass, I just wish that compost quality had not declined so much and so quickly. I even sieve out the chunks of wood and use them for drainage in the bottom of pots, but that is not the point!

Comments

  • jennyhewitt

    07 February 2008, 04.35PM

    Have you tried B&Q Seed and Cutting Compost? I found this to be the best last season almost totally lump free! and at 2 bags for £10.00 a bargain.

  • puschkins

    07 February 2008, 06.57PM

    I know exactly what you mean about rubbish in the compost. I have even found half a biro in a bag from one of the brand leaders, and the compost was lousy too. My best compost is that sold in Wicks shops, its so good I enjoy running my fingers through it!!

  • Pippa

    08 February 2008, 05.20PM

    I agree with you Pippa, I have used Levingtons Multi-purpoose compost for years and years, but like you I find wood chippings, twigs added in the ingredients. though I must add it does not seem to have an adverse effect on the seedlings.

  • KarenT

    11 February 2008, 08.24PM

    I bought some grow bags this weekend and was shocked to find glass in there. I was crumbling the lumps in my hand and the piece of glass nearly stuck into my finger. Also in the mix was those green garden tie wraps which I didn't mind as much. I have been wearing my gardening gloves ever since while dealing with it.

  • Starlight

    12 February 2008, 04.34AM

    I've just bought a compost with added John Innes after a bad lumpy, woody experience with an own brand make. The new compost is so beautiful, it's softer, easier to sow in and richer to touch, so i've learnt with compost as with most things in life you get what you pay for!!! PS it was buy two bags and get a third free, what a bargain!!

  • Angie

    12 February 2008, 02.34PM

    John Innes is good, but it contains peat, which is a no no for me. Has anyone tried any of the coir based composts? They're supposed to be great for seedlings.

  • azz

    15 February 2008, 01.30PM

    i use j arther bowers, it's lovely.

  • neil bryant

    15 February 2008, 03.46PM

    I use clover multi-purpose compost and I have never found any lumps or twigs in it and 3 bags for 10 pounds. I find this very reasonable.

  • neil bryant

    15 February 2008, 03.46PM

    I use clover multi-purpose compost and I have never found any lumps or twigs in it and 3 bags for 10 pounds. I find this very reasonable.

  • Eileen

    01 January 2007, 12.00AM

    Pippa - where can I buy the sieve that you are using as mine is finer and takes ages to sieve anything? I agree with your comments about the seed compost. I also find large lumps in mine and will try B & Q as someone suggested.

  • Pippa greenwood

    11 March 2008, 12.14PM

    Interesting to hear all the comments about brands and quality, and another glass person too. Appalling, but good to hear that some of those own brands are proving good, the sieve was from a local garden centre, try a good centre and you should find them at this time of year.

  • Kate, gardenersworld.com - reply to Mick

    31 March 2008, 05.06PM

    Hi Mick, you can find out more about growing potatoes in a container by watching one of our new video projects. Try planting potatoes in a bin or growing potatoes in a bag. Hope this helps, Kate

  • Roger

    03 May 2008, 02.13PM

    I had a bonfire with the scraps of wood I found in my last 3 bags of compost from B&Q, with a bit of patience I could have held a barbecue.

Leave a comment

We'd love you to post a comment, but please be aware of our Code of Conduct.

Please email gworld@bbc.co.uk to report any comments you feel are inappropriate. Please detail the post title and the comment you are referring to in your email. We'll take a look, and take appropriate action.

By submitting your contribution to this site, you confirm your acceptance of the website terms.

Thank you for your comment

Thank you for your comments. All comments will be looked at by a moderator, however, due to the numbers of comments we receive, we can't promise that all will be posted on the site.

 

Subscribe to the magazine

May edition of Gardeners' World Magazine

In May...
The May issue is on sale from 29 April. Subscribe today and receive the next three issues of Gardeners' World magazine for just £1.

The UK's number 1 gardening magazine

Our show

BBC Gardener's World Live

Gardeners' World Live, 11-15 June 2008

See details

TV & Radio

Television icon

What's on this week

Find out what gardening programmes are on TV and radio this week. And read more about the Gardeners' World programme.

Offer

Planter

Buy a Felco pruning set for just £44.99

BBC Magazines

© BBC Magazines Ltd. BBC Worldwide Ltd.

The BBC Gardeners' World Magazine word mark and logo are trademarks of BBC Worldwide Ltd.

BBC Magazines is owned by the BBC and our profits are returned to the BBC for the benefit of the licence-fee payer.